Thyroid cancer burden and economic impact on the Brazilian public health system

ABSTRACT Objective: Recent data indicates an increasing incidence of thyroid cancer not accompanied by a proportional increase in mortality, suggesting overdiagnosis, which may represent a big public health problem, particularly where resources are scarce. This article aims to describe and evaluate the procedures related to investigation of thyroid nodules and treatment and follow-up of thyroid cancer and the costs for the Brazilian public health system between 2008 and 2015. Materials and methods: Data on procedures related to investigation of thyroid nodules and treatment/follow-up of thyroid cancer between 2008 and 2015 in Brazil were collected from the Department of Informatics of the Brazilian Unified Health System (Datasus) website. Results: A statistically significant increase in the use of procedures related to thyroid nodules investigation and thyroid cancer treatment and follow-up was observed in Brazil, though a reduction was noted for procedures related to the treatment of more aggressive thyroid cancer, such as total thyroidectomy with neck dissection and higher radioiodine activities such as 200 and 250 milicuries (mCi). The procedures related to thyroid nodules investigation costs increased by 91% for thyroid ultrasound (p = 0.0003) and 128% in thyroid nodule biopsy (p < 0.001). Costs related to treatment and follow-up related-procedures increased by 120%. Conclusion: The increase in the incidence of thyroid cancer in Brazil is directly associated with an increased use of diagnostic tools for thyroid nodules, which leads to an upsurge in thyroid cancer treatment and followup-related procedures. These data suggest that substantial resources are being used for diagnosis, treatment and follow-up of a potentially indolent condition.

Effectiveness of harmonic scalpel in patients submitted to total thyroidectomy: systematic review with meta-analysis

SUMMARY OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to evaluate the efficacy and safety of the harmonic scalpel compared to the conventional technique in patients submitted to total thyroidectomy. METHOD: This is a systematic review with inclusion of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) that compared both techniques. An electronic search was carried out in the Medline and Lilacs databases until June 2017. The outcomes analysed were operation time, intraoperative bleeding, surgical morbidity, and costs. RESULTS: Data from 31 primary studies were included. The use of the harmonic scalpel correlates to a shorter operation time (p <0.001) and a lower volume of intraoperative bleeding (p <0.001). There were no differences in the risk of transient (p = 0.53) and permanent (p = 0.70) hypocalcaemia, transient (p = 0.61) and permanent (p = 0.50) dysfunctions of the inferior laryngeal nerve and hematoma (p = 0.14). CONCLUSION: Total thyroidectomy using a harmonic scalpel is effective and safe compared to the conventional technique.

Economic analysis of routine neuromonitoring of recurrent laryngeal nerve in total thyroidectomy / Análisis económico de la monitorización neurológica rutinaria del nervio laríngeo recurrente en la tiroidectomía total

Introduction: Thyroidectomy is a common surgery. Routine searching of the recurrent laryngeal nerve is the most important strategy to avoid palsy. Neuromonitoring has been recommended to decrease recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy. Objective: To assess if neuromonitoring of recurrent laryngeal nerve during thyroidectomy is cost-effective in a developing country. Materials and methods: We designed a decision analysis to assess the cost-effectiveness of recurrent laryngeal nerve neuromonitoring. For probabilities, we used data from a meta-analysis. Utility was measured using preference values. We considered direct costs. We conducted a deterministic and a probabilistic analysis. Results: We did not find differences in utility between arms. The frequency of recurrent laryngeal nerve injury was 1% in the neuromonitor group and 1.6% for the standard group. Thyroidectomy without monitoring was the less expensive alternative. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio was COP$ 9,112,065. Conclusion: Routine neuromonitoring in total thyroidectomy with low risk of recurrent laryngeal nerve injury is neither cost-useful nor cost-effective in the Colombian health system.

Introducción. La tiroidectomía es una cirugía común. La búsqueda rutinaria del nervio laríngeo inferior es la estrategia más importante para evitar la parálisis. Objetivo. Evaluar el costo-efectividad en un país en desarrollo de la monitorización neurológica del nervio laríngeo inferior durante la tiroidectomía. Materiales y métodos. Se diseñó un análisis de decisiones para evaluar el costo-efectividad de la monitorización neurológica del nervio laríngeo inferior. Para las probabilidades se usaron datos de un meta-análisis. La utilidad se determinó con medidas de preferencia. Se incluyeron los costos directos. Se hizo un análisis determinístico y probabilístico. Resultados. No se encontraron diferencias en la utilidad entre las estrategias. La frecuencia de la lesión de este nervio fue de 1 % en el grupo bajo monitorización neurológica y de 1,6 % en el grupo de control. La tiroidectomía sin monitorización fue la alternativa menos costosa. La razón de costo-efectividad incremental fue de COP$ 9.112.065 Conclusión. La monitorización neurológica rutinaria en la tiroidectomía total con bajo riesgo de lesión del nervio laríngeo inferior, no es útil con relación a su costo ni costo-efectiva en el sistema de salud colombiano.

Eficacia, seguridad y eficiencia de las nuevas tecnologías en cirugía tiroidea / Effectiveness, safety and efficiency of new technologies in thyroid surgery

Introduction: Surgery of the thyroid gland is the most performed procedure by the endocrine surgeon. In the last years, new techniques have been incorporated in this procedure. Our objective is to analyse the impact of these techniques in our department. Methods: We performed a retrospective and comparative study among three samples of patients submitted for total thyroidectomy. Group I: Sample of 96 patients operated between 2004 and 2007 performing total thyroidectomy. In this period we didn't use ultrasonic scalpel (US) nor intraoperative neuromonitoring (INM). Group II: Sample of 108 patients operated between 2008 and 2010. In this group we used US for hemostasis. Group III: Sample of 82 patients operated between 2011 and 2012. In this group we used both US and INM. The groups are compared: complications, postoperative stay, surgical time and costs per patient. Results: We analysed the following complications: haemorrhage, postoperative hipocalcemia and recurrent nerve palsy. We didn't find significant differences among the samples of patients but there were a less percentage of recurrent palsy in the third group (4.9 percent vs 12.5 and 11.1 percent). We found significant differences when stay, surgical time and costs were analysed. Conclusion: The use of new techniques in thyroid surgery has supposed an improvement not only in the clinic outcomes but in the surgical time.

Objetivo: La cirugía de la glándula tiroides representa el procedimiento más frecuente que realiza el cirujano endocrino. En los últimos años se han ido incorporando nuevas técnicas aplicadas a este procedimiento. El objetivo de nuestro trabajo es analizar el impacto que dichas técnicas han tenido en nuestro servicio. Material y Métodos: Estudio retrospectivo y comparativo entre tres muestras de pacientes a los que se realizó tiroidectomía total. Grupo I: Muestra de 96 pacientes intervenidos entre 2004 y 2007 a los que se realizó tiroidectomía total. En este período no se utilizó bisturí ultrasónico (BU) ni neuromonitorización intraoperatoria (NMI). Grupo II: Muestra de 108 pacientes intervenidos entre 2008 y 2010. En este grupo se realizó hemostasia con BU. Grupo III: Muestra de 82 pacientes intervenidos entre 2011 y 2012. Se utilizó tanto el BU como la NMI. Se comparan los grupos en cuanto a: complicaciones, estancia postoperatoria, tiempo quirúrgico y coste por paciente. Resultados: Las complicaciones analizadas fueron: hemorragia, hipocalcemia postoperatoria y parálisis del nervio laríngeo recurrente. No encontramos diferencias significativas entre los grupos aunque sí hay una menor tasa de parálisis recurrenciales en el tercer período (4,9 por ciento vs 12,5 y 11,1 por ciento). Hemos obtenido diferencias significativas en estancia, tiempo quirúrgico y coste por paciente. Conclusión: La inclusión de las nuevas técnicas en cirugía tiroidea ha supuesto una mejora en los resultados clínicos así como un ahorro de tiempo de quirófano.

Comparação da anestesia geral e bloqueio do plexo cervical superficial em tireoidectomias parciais / Comparison between general anesthesia and superficial cervical plexus block in partial thyroidectomies

Tireoidectomia sob efeito de bloqueio do plexo cervical superficial (BPCS) tem sofrido resistência. OBJETIVO: Comparar variáveis cirúrgicas e anestésicas, custos do tratamento e grau de satisfação de pacientes submetidos à hemitireoidectomia sob efeito de anestesia geral e BPCS. CASUÍSTICA E MÉTODOS: Foram 21 pacientes submetidos à anestesia geral (AG) e outro tanto ao BPCS. Após sedação, no grupo com BPCS, usou-se marcaína com vasoconstritor, e quando necessário, lidocaína a 2 por cento com vasoconstritor. Sedação intra-operatória com diazepam endovenoso e metoprolol para controle da PA e FC eram administradas quando necessário. Usou-se anestesia geral (AG) segundo padronização do serviço. RESULTADOS: Foram significantes (p<0,05, teste t de Student) para o tempo de cirurgia (ag111,4:bpcs125,5 min), tempo de anestesia (ag154,1:bpcs488,6 min), tempo de permanência na sala cirúrgica (ag15:bpcs1 min), custos do tratamento (ag203,2:bpcs87,4 R$), presença de bradicardia (ag0:bpcs23,8 por cento) e lesão laringotraqueal (ag51:bpcs0 por cento). Como resultados não significativos tiveram: tempo de internação (ag17,3:bpcs15,1 hora); volume de sangramento (ag41,9:bpcs47,6 gr), tamanho da peça operatória (ag52,1:bpcs93,69 cm3) e grau de satisfação dos pacientes (ag3,8:bpcs3,9). CONCLUSÃO: Embora com incidência maior de bradicardia (23,8 por cento), o bloqueio permitiu ressecar tumorações de até 348 cm3 com menor custo e sem apresentar lesões laringotraqueais, presentes em 51 por cento dos pacientes submetidos à AG.

Thyroidectomy under the effect of superficial cervical plexus block (SCPB) has met resistance. AIM: to compare variables in patients submitted to hemithyroidectomy under the effect of general anesthesia (GA) and SCPB. CASE REPORT AND METHODS: GA was used in 21 patients, and SCPB was used in another 21 patients. Following sedation, marcaine 0.5 percent with vasoconstrictor was used in the SCPB group. Intraoperative sedation with diazepam and metoprolol to control arterial pressure and cardiac frequency was given as needed. GA followed the standard method in the unit. RESULTS: We found significant results (p<0.05, Student’s t-test) for surgery time (GA - 111.4 min; SCPB - 125.5 min), anesthesia time (GA - 154.1 min; SCPB - 488.6 min), time in the surgery room (GA - 15 min; SCPB - 1 min), treatment costs (GA - R$203.2; SCPB - R$87.4), presence of bradycardia (GA - 0; SCPB - 23.8 percent) and laryngotracheal injury (GA - 51; SCPB - 0 percent). We also found the following non-significant results: hospitalization time (GA - 17.3; SCPB - 15.1 hours); bleeding volume (GA - 41,9 g; SCPB - 47.6 g), size of the operative specimen (GA - 52.1 cm3; SCPB - 93.69 cm3) and patient satisfaction level (GA - 3.8; SCPB - 3.9). CONCLUSION: Although the incidence of bradycardia was higher (23.8 percent), SCPB was done for the resection of tumors measuring up to 348 cm3, at a lower cost and with no laryngotracheal injuries; these were present in 51 percent of patients undergoing GA.